Lane v Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust & Anor
[2017] EWHC 1900 (QB)·2017·Liability decided at trial
After a heart attack and angioplasty, Mrs Lane developed a blocked artery in her right arm; it was diagnosed at 02:30 but she was not transferred to the vascular unit until the morning and thrombectomy was done that evening. The judge found the delays and surgery were not negligent and that, in any event, the arm was successfully reperfused so the later amputation was not caused by any delay.
Delay alone is not enough: a claimant must show both that the delay fell below a reasonable standard and that earlier treatment would have changed the outcome. Deferring surgery for an unstable cardiac patient can be a reasonable clinical judgment.