Every one a published decision of the courts of England and Wales, linked to its source.
Claimant succeeded£811,247
[2026] EWHC 657 (KB)·2026·Damages assessed at trial
The trust admitted it negligently failed to diagnose Daisy Lynch's developmental hip dysplasia at birth, so it was not picked up until she was three, by which time simple non-surgical treatment was no longer possible. She went through repeated hip operations and a total hip replacement at 22, and the court assessed her damages after an eight-day trial.
Even where liability is admitted, damages can be heavily contested, and the court can add a provisional damages order letting the claimant return for more if a specified complication later occurs. The award covered pain and suffering, lost earnings, future care and future surgery.
Claimant succeeded
[2011] EWHC 219 (QB)·2011·Liability decided at trial
A GP re-examined a nine-week-old baby's hips after a colleague had noted they were stiff, recorded them as seeming fine and did not refer her to an orthopaedic specialist; the dislocated right hip was only discovered when she was seven and needed major surgery. The judge found the GP should have detected the limited hip movement and referred immediately, and that early referral would have led to simpler treatment.
When an infant hip check raises concern, a GP must refer for specialist assessment rather than arranging a distant re-check. Missing a dislocated hip in infancy turns a condition treatable with a splint into one needing major surgery.
Mixed outcome
[2020] EWHC 1504 (QB)·2020·Liability decided at trial
A baby born breech by caesarean should have had a hip ultrasound within six weeks, but the appointment was not arranged until nine weeks and, after rescheduling, the scan at 17 weeks showed hip dysplasia in both hips, needing surgery. The Trust admitted breach but, shortly before trial, sought to blame the mother's missed appointment; the judge refused the late amendment.
Babies born breech need a timely hip scan, and a trust's failure to arrange one within its own protocol was admitted as negligent. Defendants cannot raise new causation arguments on the eve of trial without good reason.
Claimant succeeded
[2023] EWHC 2719 (KB)·2023·Liability decided at trial
Two radiologists reporting a newborn's abdominal X-rays in October 2010 did not identify or report abnormal alignment of the hips that was visible on the films. The hip dysplasia was not diagnosed until 14 months later and the court found both radiologists in breach of duty.
Radiologists must report any obvious abnormality visible on an X-ray, even if it is outside the reason the scan was ordered. A missed incidental finding can found a negligence claim.
Claimant succeeded
[2025] EWHC 2121 (KB)·2025·Liability decided at trial
A 25-year-old with congenital heart disease suffered a severe brain injury when her aorta was cut during a high-risk repeat sternotomy and it took around 24 minutes to get her onto full bypass. The judge found the surgeon should have exposed the femoral vessels in advance (saving around 13 minutes) and that consent was deficient; she would still have gone ahead with the operation, but with that precaution taken.
Surgeons planning a known high-risk operation must take reasonable precautions beforehand and tell the patient about them; a court can find negligence in planning and consent even where the intra-operative error itself was not negligent.